Disclosure: this post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Most buyers read the number on a sleeping bag as a promise: a 0°F bag keeps you comfortable at 0°F. It does not, and the gap matters most on the night the bag is actually needed, when a winter outage shuts off the heat and the bedroom gets colder by the hour. On the Gulf Coast, where houses are built to shed heat rather than hold it, a hard freeze with the power out can leave a bedroom colder than most households here have planned for.
This guide explains the numbers makers put on sleeping bags (temperature, comfort, limit and extreme), how the three makers we cover label their own bags, and how to read a rating against a cold house rather than a campsite. Every definition comes from a maker’s own explanation and every figure from a maker’s product page. The bags themselves are compared in our cold-weather sleeping bag roundup.
The Numbers on a Sleeping Bag
Many makers test their bags to the EN ISO 23537 standard. Rab, which rates most of its bags to it, describes the method: “A thermal mannequin is placed into the sleeping bag being tested, on a standard foam roll mat,” and a series of measurements shows how well the bag insulates at different temperatures. Rab defines three ratings from that test.
| Rating | How Rab defines it | What it means in a cold house |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | “the minimum temperature where an individual can sleep in a relaxed position and get a good night’s sleep” | The number to match to your bedroom |
| Limit (Rab: Limit of Comfort) | “the lowest temperature where a person sleeping in a curled position and fighting against the cold” can still sleep through the night | A bad night, not a plan |
| Extreme | An emergency figure: “the minimum temperature a person can remain in the sleeping bag for up to six hours,” curled up and fighting the cold | Never a planning figure |
Rab says it names its sleeping bags by the Limit of Comfort rating, which differs from its Comfort rating. Not every maker does that, which is why the number in a bag’s name can mean different things from brand to brand. When a page shows only one number and does not say which rating it is, you cannot assume it is the comfort figure.
How Coleman, Teton and Kelty Label Their Bags
Teton publishes two numbers and explains both. Its ratings are “Survival Temperature Ratings,” which Teton defines as “the coldest temperature the sleeping bag is designed to keep you alive in,” and it says plainly that the rating “doesn’t guarantee comfort.” For comfort, Teton suggests adding 20 to 30 degrees to the listed rating, and for the Celsius Regular it publishes both: a 0°F temperature rating and a 25°F to 30°F comfort temperature rating.
Coleman publishes one number per bag and no comfort, limit or extreme figure. The North Rim page says “Stay warm in temperatures as low as 0°F”; the Brazos page says the same at 20°F; the Heritage Big and Tall lists a “Minimum Temperature Rating” of 10. Asked for the North Rim’s comfort rating on the product page, Coleman’s consumer care team repeated that it “is rated for use down to 0°F” and added that “actual comfort can vary based on your clothing, sleeping pad, and personal warmth preferences.”
Kelty lists a single “Temperature Rating: 20°F / -7°C” for the Cosmic Down 20, with no comfort or limit figure on the page, and the page does not say which test figure the 20°F represents.
| Bag | Headline rating | Comfort figure | What the maker says the headline means |
|---|---|---|---|
| TETON Sports Celsius Regular | 0°F | 25°F to 30°F | A survival rating: the coldest temperature the bag is designed to keep you alive in |
| Coleman North Rim | 0°F | Not published | “Stay warm in temperatures as low as 0°F”; comfort “can vary” (consumer care) |
| Coleman Heritage Big and Tall | 10°F | Not published | “Minimum Temperature Rating” |
| Coleman Brazos | 20°F | Not published | “Stay warm in temperatures as low as 20°F” |
| Kelty Cosmic Down 20 | 20°F / -7°C | Not published on the page | “Temperature Rating” only; the page does not say which test figure it is |
Teton’s rule of thumb belongs to Teton’s own survival ratings. Coleman and Kelty publish no conversion from their headline numbers to comfort, so there is no maker figure to apply to their bags, and we will not invent one. If the maker does not define its headline number, do not relabel it as a comfort, limit or survival rating.
Reading a Rating Against a Cold House
- Measure the room. A thermometer in the bedroom you will use tells you more than any forecast. Check it at bedtime and again before dawn on the first night of an outage.
- Match the comfort figure where there is one. If the bag publishes a comfort rating, it should be at or below what the thermometer reads.
- Treat a single number as a floor. If the bag publishes only a temperature rating, leave a wide margin between it and the room, and plan to add layers.
- Put something under the bag. The standard test puts the bag on a foam mat, and Coleman’s own answer names the sleeping pad as one of the things that changes comfort. A bed, a cot or a pad beats a bare floor.
- Add layers on top. A blanket over the bag, and a mylar blanket as the outer shell if you have one.
- Know when the bag is not enough. If the room keeps falling or anyone cannot stay warm, it is time to leave. Ready.gov’s advice is to go to a community location with power if heat or cold is extreme.
A House in the 50s Versus a Hard Freeze
If your closed-up house holds the bedroom in the 50s, every bag in our roundup has a headline rating at least 30 degrees below the room, and the one bag with a published comfort range, the Teton Celsius, sits 20 or more degrees below it even on its comfort figure. At that temperature, the choice of bag is about fit and bulk, not rating.
A hard freeze with no heat for a day or more is different, and nobody can tell you in advance how far a particular house will fall: it depends on the insulation, the windows, the wind and how long the freeze lasts. That is the night to want a bag whose comfort figure, not its headline, covers the room. Of the bags we cover, only the Teton Celsius publishes one (25°F to 30°F). For the others, a 0°F headline, such as the Coleman North Rim, leaves more room than a 20°F one, and our guide to staying warm when the power goes out in winter covers what the rest of the house should be doing while you sleep.
What the Rating Assumes: A Pad and Dry Insulation
A rating describes a bag on a mat, not a bag on cold tile. Rab’s description of the test, a mannequin in the bag “on a standard foam roll mat,” means the published figures already count on insulation underneath. Lay the same bag on a bare slab floor and the rating no longer describes what you are doing. Coleman says as much when it lists the sleeping pad among the things that change comfort.
A rating also describes dry insulation, and Gulf Coast houses are humid. Rab says synthetic insulation keeps much of its warmth when wet and that it dries much more quickly than down; down’s advantage is warmth for its weight. Our sources document synthetic fill for the North Rim and the Teton Celsius and down for the Kelty Cosmic Down 20; the Heritage and Brazos pages do not identify their fill. Keep any bag dry, and air it out in the morning.
Layering: Blankets, Clothing and Mylar
The CDC lists extra blankets, sleeping bags and warm winter coats as the backup heat sources to have when the power goes out, and Ready.gov’s kit list asks for a sleeping bag or warm blanket for each person. A blanket over the bag adds warmth without changing what the label means; no maker we cover publishes a figure for how much it adds, so we will not estimate one.
Clothing inside the bag works the same way, with one caution. The National Weather Service’s winter advice is to wear layers of loose-fitting, lightweight, warm clothing and to remove layers to avoid overheating, perspiration and the chill that follows. Sweat matters: the CDC notes that hypothermia can occur even at cool temperatures above 40°F if a person becomes chilled from rain, sweat or cold water. Dress warm enough to sleep, not so warm that you wake up damp.
A mylar blanket is the last layer, not the first. It stops wind and reflects some radiant heat, but it has no insulation of its own and it traps moisture; our mylar thermal blankets review and our emergency blankets, bivvies and tarps roundup explain how to use it over a sleeping bag and why it cannot replace one.
What This Guide Does Not Cover
We do not test or rate sleeping bags; every figure here is the maker’s, and where a maker publishes none, we say so rather than estimate. This guide is not medical advice and does not cover how to recognize or treat cold injuries; the CDC’s winter weather pages do. It does not cover sleeping bags for babies: the CDC’s advice, if you cannot keep the home warm, is to make temporary arrangements to stay elsewhere. And an extreme rating is never a plan for a house; it describes a night of survival, not sleep.
Common Questions
Will a 0°F bag keep me comfortable at 0°F?
Not by the makers’ own descriptions. Teton calls its 0°F a survival rating and publishes a comfort range of 25°F to 30°F for the same bag. Coleman publishes no comfort figure for its 0°F North Rim and says comfort varies with clothing, the pad and the sleeper. Plan on comfort sitting above the headline number.
Why can two bags with the same number feel so different?
Because the number does not always mean the same thing. Rab names bags by their comfort rating, Teton by a survival rating, and Coleman and Kelty publish a single figure without saying which test rating it corresponds to. Compare comfort figures where they exist, and leave a wide margin below a lone headline number.
Does a blanket or a liner change the rating?
The rating stays what it is; in the ISO-style test Rab describes, it is measured on the bag alone on a foam mat, and makers that publish a single headline figure do not say how they test. A blanket over the bag adds warmth, but no maker we cover publishes a figure for how much, so the honest answer is “some,” and the thermometer and how you feel at 3 a.m. are the test.
Bottom Line
Read the comfort figure, not the headline. A single headline rating is not defined the same way by every maker, a comfort figure is the number to match to your bedroom, and the extreme figure is never a plan. Put a pad under the bag, a blanket over it, keep it dry, and leave for a place with heat if the room keeps falling. When you want a maker’s comfort figure to plan around, the TETON Sports Celsius Regular is the bag we point to: Teton publishes a 25°F to 30°F comfort rating alongside its 0°F survival rating, for sleepers up to 5 ft 8 in.
Sources
- Rab: Sleeping Bag Temperature Ratings Explained
- Rab: Should I Pick Down or Synthetic Insulation?
- TETON Sports: Celsius Regular 0°F Sleeping Bag
- Coleman: North Rim Adult Mummy Sleeping Bag
- Coleman: Heritage Big and Tall Sleeping Bag
- Coleman: Brazos 20°F Sleeping Bag
- Kelty: Cosmic Down 20 Sleeping Bag
- CDC: Safety Guidelines During and After a Winter Storm
- CDC: Preventing Hypothermia
- National Weather Service: What To Do If You’re Caught in a Winter Storm
- Ready.gov: Power Outages
- Ready.gov: Build a Kit
Some links on this page are Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, Ultimate Prepper’s Guide may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
